A Day At Fort Holmes

Call this a follow up to my previous “A Day At Fort Mackinac” three years later…

The first clear view of Fort Holmes as you clear the steps up the hillside. I think the “No Climbing” sign is the first line of defense to stop intruders.

Fort Mackinac was built during the American Revolution by the British Army. It is one of only two Revolutionary War forts still existent in the United States. At least that’s what the tour guide said? She referenced the other at St Augustine, Fl. I didn’t think to ask, but if she meant Castillo de San Marcos, that was complete in 1695. So perhaps Ft Mackinac is really the only such fort in existence? Seems hard to believe, but of course most construction of the era was timber, so is unlikely to survive. Ft Mackinac is limestone.

Waiting for the ferry to the Island. Its October, and we went North on vacation…

And this all leads to Ft Holmes. When Ft Mackinac was completed in 1781 the British Army engineers observed that the highest ground on the island, 1/4 mile directly uphill and inland from the new fort, needed to be fortified to protect the “back door” (at 310 feet above the Straits of Mackinac surface level). When American forces took control of the Fort in 1783 they surveyed the site and noted that the high ground directly behind the fort needed to be fortified…

The view from the earthworks to Fort Mackinac. The white building is part of the bigger fort..
Sorry the focus isn’t quite right! This is zoomed a little, but what I wanted to show is the ferry boat (right of center, with rooster tail) approaching the docks in Haldiman Bay. Even though the village is out of sight from here, it and the Fort are on a pretty small chunk of real estate at the foot of the hill. A couple of field guns up here could easily target both, and that’s what the British threatened to do!

So I’m guessing you can see where this going even if you didn’t read my previous post? In 1812, during the War of 1812, British forces landed on Mackinac Island, took the high ground behind the Fort, and forced the US Army garrison to surrender by threatening to shell both Fort and the town in its shadow. Once the British had control of the Fort and Island they built a fortification called “Fort George” on that high spot. It was a simple earthen redoubt surrounding a wooden block house/observation tower.

This view is more to the North. Sadly, it didn’t occur to me to point the camera right at the landing grounds. But this generally shows the advantage of this position!

When American forces tried to replicate the British capture of the Fort, their approach to the island was seen from Fort George and and their force was met by the British in a field 2 miles north. The American force was turned back, among the fatalities was Major Andrew Holmes, the second in command.

The front gate (east) side. The gate side is obviously flat, the rest of the shape is a horseshoe.
Interior view of Fort Holmes and its blockhouse. [photo via tripadviser]
The 1936 reconstruction included an exterior storage building. [photo via MLive]

The following year, 1815, the War was over and Mackinac Island reverted to American control. The US Army was happy to have the fortified high ground, but not so happy with it named for the British King. So it was renamed in honor of Major Holmes.

The front of Fort Mackinac. Seasonal colors and limestone walls.

Through the rest of the 19th Century the US/Canadian border become much less volatile, and the military structures became less important. Part of that meant the timber Fort Holmes was allowed to fall into disrepair. The timber was even pilfered and used to construct other buildings on the island. Most of the island, including the sites of Fort Mackinac and Fort Holmes were made Park land in 1875. The US’s second National Park at first, but then one of Michigan’s first State Parks in 1895. That made this the State Park’s 125th Anniversary.

As we all know, 2020 became sort of a dud year for a big celebration. But Northern Michigan has had low impact from Corona Virus and always been one or two “Phases” more open than the more densely populated southern part of the State. So it was an appealing escape for us. The first week of October is considered “peak color” for that area so we chose an appropriate time. Of course, travel north this time of year is not for the faint of heart! Especially not for anyone dreading the approach of winter anyway. But hey, the good news is, we discovered the required masks actually add a lot of warmth!
Many years back we had visited the site of Fort Holmes. Its a bit off the beaten path and less accessible than the fudge shops. But not too bad. On that occasion we had taken along our bikes and got to the site from winding trails on the north side. There had been a reconstruction of Fort Holmes built on the location in 1936 (a project of FDR’s WPA) from the Army’s 1817 survey work. But by the time we first got there (c. 2005) the construction was long gone except for the earth works.
This time, we thought it would be fun to get to that high point again just for the great view. We were on foot, so took the shorter south route. From that side the last 100 feet of the climb are by a scenic wooden staircase up the hillside. That was fun! And what a view.
But there was a total bonus neither of us knew about. Apparently, in 2015, the Park had done another complete restoration of the site. Now I wasn’t completely shocked, I had noticed earlier in the day that when I looked up the cleared lane from Fort Mackinac there was a wooden structure on top of the hill that I could see very little of. I thought maybe an observation tower (there have been at least three different towers on the hill during periods when there was no Fort. My wife and I debated whether it would be better to see a fort or an observation platform, you can guess which side I took) or part of the earthworks. But seeing a whole Fort Holmes sitting there was sort of exciting! The first picture at top is the first view as you step from the trees at the top of the steps.

A significant view on the ride out from Mackinaw City is the Mackinac Bridge that joins Michigan’s Upper and Lower Peninsulas. Completed in 1957, and still the longest suspension bridge in the US, it had major economic and social impact on the State.
Among the first recognizable landmarks as one approaches Mackinac Island is the Grand Hotel.
Typical, well actually the low traffic version of typical street scene on Mackinac Island.
The south shore of the island has dozens of Victorian summer cottages. A practical choice for anyone with several million dollars to spend on a home you can only use 5-6 months out of the year…
View from our room at Mission Point Resort.

About atcDave

I'm 5o-something years old and live in Ypsilanti, Michigan. I'm happily married to Jodie. I was an air traffic controller for 33 years and recently retired; grew up in the Chicago area, and am still a fanatic for pizza and the Chicago Bears. My main interest is military history, and my related hobbies include scale model building and strategy games.
This entry was posted in Museums and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to A Day At Fort Holmes

  1. Ernie Davis says:

    I’ll have to read the whole post more thoroughly, but your one caption amused me.

    “The first clear view of Fort Holmes as you clear the steps up the hillside. I think the “No Climbing” sign is the first line of defense to stop intruders.”

    There is a story, perhaps apocryphal, that in the early days of WWI there was a British officer who refused to leave the road and cut across country because it was private property and the Belgians were their allies.

    • atcDave says:

      That’s funny! No doubt such concerns come up.
      A similar, but more positive version I’ve heard of that is late in the Napoleonic Wars, much of the French citizenry decided they preferred having the British Army around than the French; because the British actually PAID for the goods they took! Apparently Napoleon thought it was the French people’s duty to support their army. Not unreasonable perhaps, but it failed him badly on a practical level.

  2. Pierre Lagacé says:

    Thanks for the tour Dave.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s